Christmas Coffee Creamer Recipe: A Sugar Cookie Delight (2024)

Just so you know, if you click on a product on RoastyCoffee.com and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

Christmas is right around the corner and along with the happy holiday comes yummy, warm, and comforting seasonal drinks. Local coffee shops seem to always have something new when it comes to Christmas coffee flavors.

From gingerbread to peppermint mocha, there are so many options to choose from in the fan-favorite Christmas flavors. This even goes for store-bought holiday coffee creamer flavors!

In recent years, one of the more popular festive flavors for coffee seems to be sugar cookie. That’s why I chose this tasty flavor to show you how to make your own homemade Christmas coffee creamer for a scrumptious morning brew!

What is Sugar Cookie Christmas Coffee Creamer?

The sugar cookie has made a boom in the Christmas coffee world, with several coffee shops adding syrup flavors that taste just like the festive sweet treat.

Not only that but there have also been several coffee creamers made, such as International Delight’s sugar cookie flavor.

So if you’ve had your fill of the spices that come with gingerbread and eggnog flavors, why not try out a sweet and comforting flavor that tastes like it just came right out of the oven?

Make Your Own Christmas Coffee Creamer

That being said, let me show you just how to make a sugar-cookie-flavored Christmas coffee creamer within the warm comfort of your own home.

While the fire is burning and the tree is glistening, this homemade coffee creamer recipe can be made in minutes so that you can have a warm, toasty cup of coffee to watch your favorite holiday movie with.

Ingredients:

• 1/2 cup of sweetened condensed milk
• 1/2 cup of whole milk
• 1/4 teaspoon of almond extract
• 1/4 teaspoon of vanilla extract
• Sealable airtight container

Process:

Step 1:

First, you want to pour the sweetened condensed milk into the sealable container.

For this recipe, I used a mason jar for easier shaking and storing.

Step 2:

Next, you can add the milk to the container. This can be any milk of your preference, but I used whole milk when I made it.

Step 3:

To the sweetened condensed milk and liquid milk, add the almond extract. Be careful not to use more than directed, as it can vastly change the taste of the creamer.

Step 4:

Finally, add the vanilla extract, close the container, and shake it up to thoroughly mix the ingredients.

And that’s it! Now you have a yummy Christmas coffee creamer to share with all your family and friends. Or you can keep it to yourself, your secret’s safe with me!

View our Google web story here.

Some Tips and Tricks

When I made this sugar cookie Christmas coffee creamer recipe, I paired it with a simple two shots of espresso. This worked perfectly to give a warm and sweet addition to my caffeine fix.

However, I later steamed up some of this creamer to add to my favorite drip coffee. This brought out the flavors even more, giving those cozy, warm, and Christmasy vibes from a cup of coffee that tasted just like a sweet, frosted sugar cookie.

Whichever way you choose to use this sugar cookie coffee creamer, just make sure you only keep it in the refrigerator for up to a week and shake it up before every use!

Christmas Coffee Creamer: Final Thoughts

So, now that you have your own fun holiday coffee creamer, in the most scrumptious flavor no less, the coffee creations are endless!

I hope this super easy recipe inspired you to either whip up your own batch of sugar cookie creamer or add your own spin to it using your favorite coffee.

I know I’ll be making some more as the holiday season rolls ever closer. This has to be one of my favorite creamer flavors. Especially on cold days, a warm cup of coffee with that baked cookie flavor has me wanting to curl up with a good book next to a blazing fire and a decorated Christmas tree.

Now, what are you waiting for? Go make your very own sugar cookie Christmas coffee creamer!

Happy Caffeinating!

Yield: 1

Cook Time: 2 minutes

Total Time: 2 minutes

This super easy sugar cookie Christmas coffee creamer is warm, comforting, tasty, and has all of your favorite things about baked cookies on a chilly winter day rolled into one!

Ingredients

• 1/2 cup sweetened condensed milk
• 1/2 cup milk
• 1/4 tsp almond extract
• 1/4 tsp vanilla extract
• sealable airtight container

See Also

32 All-Time Favorite Christmas Cookie Recipes

Instructions

1. Pour sweetened condensed milk into the container.
2. Add milk to the container.
3. Add almond extract to the container.
4. Add vanilla extract to the container, close it and shake it thoroughly.

Share the goods

Recommended Reads

• Coffee Facts

  Macchiato vs Latte: The Expressions of Espresso

  Lately, there seems to be a disconnect between the lingo used in chain coffee shops and that used in specialty shops. That disconnect makes it even harder for coffee-lovers to distinguish between combinations of milk and espresso. We're here to help you figure it out! Read on to see the breakdown of macchiato vs latte.

• How to Brew

  Toasted Coconut Cold Brew Recipe: Starbucks at Home!

• How to Brew

  Our Iced Coffee Keurig Guide: Delicious, Refreshing Brews

  We can all appreciate a refreshing iced coffee every now and again. But whose budget can sustain a daily trip to the coffee shop? Not ours. So we decided to figure out how make iced coffee with a Keurig in the comfort of your own home. Stay tuned to find out how it's done.

• Coffee Facts

  Americano vs. Coffee: Taste and Caffeine Levels

  An Americano coffee is an espresso drink that's diluted in hot water to separate itself from regular drip coffee and a shot of espresso.

• How to Brew

  Sweet And Simple Vanilla Bean Frappuccino Recipe

  This copycat vanilla bean frappuccino recipe will satisfy any sweet tooth and can be styled differently with one shot of espresso!

• How to Brew

  Campfire S’mores Latte Recipe

Related Posts

More from How to Brew