Diesel Engines vs. Gasoline Engines: Pros & Cons | Sun Auto Service (2024)

Shopping for a new car can be a daunting process. Sedan or SUV? Truck or van? Hybrid or electric?

Gasoline or diesel?

In the past you could cut down that list by half if you decided you wanted a diesel-powered vehicle as until recently, most diesels were only available in trucks.

Now, you have the option to purchase many vehicles with a diesel engine option. Gone are the days of a stinky car spewing soot as it chugs down the road. With vast improvements over the decades, diesel engines have been engineered to produce less soot and improve their carbon footprint.

Should your next vehicle purchase be a diesel-fueled model? Find out with the pros and cons of diesel versus gasoline engines.

Diesel vs. Gasoline Engines

Diesel and gasoline engines use the same concept when it comes to expanding fuel. Both are internal combustion engines that transfer chemical energy from fuel to mechanical energy which forces the movement of pistons in the cylinders. The pistons are connected to the crankshaft which generates motion to create power to move the vehicle.

Diesel and gasoline engines are combustible engines which means they convert fuel into energy with small explosions. How the explosions occur is where each engine differs.

Gasoline is delivered to the engine and is mixed with air and then is compressed by the pistons and ignited from the sparks made from the spark plugs.

Diesel engines on the other hand, compress the air before the fuel is directly injected into the combustion chamber. Diesel engines do not require spark plugs because highly compressed air heats up and causes the fuel to ignite. Diesel Engines vs. Gasoline Engines: Pros & Cons | Sun Auto Service (1)

Diesel Pros:

  • Superior towing capabilities, enhanced torque, better take offs
  • Improved fuel efficiency, less fill ups
  • Improved noise level and smoother performance from earlier diesel models
  • More fuel efficient, decreased carbon emissions, cleaner than primitive diesel engines
  • Fewer engine components, no tune-ups

Diesel Cons:

  • Abysmal horsepower, slower speed
  • Expensive fuel, limited gas stations with diesel
  • Noisier and more rugged ride than gasoline-powered engines
  • Produce emissions that emit carcinogens, nitrous oxides, and soot into the atmosphere
  • Costlier repairs and maintenance

Engine Power

Have you ever wondered why so many tractor trailers traverse our highways fueled by diesel? Diesel engines are able to produce a great amount of low-end torque.

A diesel-fueled car has more “get up and go” accelerating quickly from a complete stop in comparison to a gasoline-fueled car. Diesel engine vehicles also have better towing abilities. If you’re planning on towing a boat, toy hauler, or camper, a diesel engine will make those long hauls easier.

While a diesel engine’s torque game is strong, it loses points for horsepower. Diesel fueled cars are strong, have long lasting engines, and are dependable–but they are not sporty.

Fuel Efficiency

Many vehicle owners choose diesel-fueled vehicles over gasoline models because of their increased fuel efficiency. Some diesel model passenger cars can get up to 30 percent more miles than their gasoline counterparts. Though diesel vehicles are more efficient, when it comes to diesel vs. gas prices, diesel fuel is more costly than gasoline. Diesel vehicles do very well on the highway as opposed to city driving. If you spend a lot of time traveling on highways, a diesel vehicle is an ideal option for you.

Emissions

Today’s diesel vehicles run much more cleanly than in the past, but is diesel cleaner than gas? Though they run much cleaner, diesel cars still produce higher levels of emissions including nitrous oxide and soot, especially when taking off from a complete stop. City commuters or drivers that are more environmentally conscious may want to opt for a cleaner electric or hybrid car instead of purchasing a diesel model.

Ride Quality

Diesel-powered vehicles haven’t always had the best reputation. Many people think of diesel vehicles as noisy, rattily, stinky, dirty cars. Through better engineering and development of technology, diesel cars have improved producing a smoother and quieter ride. In spite of these groundbreaking improvements, diesel engines are not as quiet or as smooth as gasoline engines.

Maintenance and Repairs

Because the diesel engine is not equipped with distributors or spark plugs, there is no need for the regular tune up that gasoline engines require. However, regular maintenance including oil changes and other maintenance services are still necessary. Just like any vehicle, failure to maintain the engine and other components can spell disaster later on. The fuel injection system, particularly in diesel engines, if not maintained can result in severe damages and costly repairs.

If you’re considering purchasing a diesel engine car, it’s important you determine what your needs will be behind the wheel. Will you be spending weekends camping in the woods, hauling a horse to shows and rodeos, hauling ATVs to the sand dunes, or are you planning to explore America’s highways and become a frequent road tripper?

If you answered no to any of these questions, you may want to consider purchasing a gasoline, hybrid, or electric vehicle to better accommodate your lifestyle. If you answered yes, a diesel-fueled vehicle is a great option for you!

Diesel Engines vs. Gasoline Engines: Pros & Cons | Sun Auto Service (2024)

FAQs

Diesel Engines vs. Gasoline Engines: Pros & Cons | Sun Auto Service? ›

Because the diesel engine is not equipped with distributors or spark plugs, there is no need for the regular tune up that gasoline engines require. However, regular maintenance including oil changes and other maintenance services are still necessary.

Do diesel engines require more maintenance than gas engines? ›

Less maintenance – With no spark plugs and less stress, diesel engines can run longer before requiring maintenance. Long lasting – Thanks to higher compression, the parts of a diesel engine suffer less wear and tear than a gas-powered engine.

Which has a higher maintenance cost, diesel or gasoline engine? ›

Although diesel engines may require fewer repair and maintenance services than gasoline engines when major repairs are needed, they are generally more expensive than their gasoline counterparts.

Are diesel engines more expensive to service? ›

Diesel engines can be more expensive to service, with their fuel system components often costing many times more than the equivalent part for a petrol engine.

Is it better to get a diesel or gas car? ›

Fuel efficiency: Diesel engines are typically much more fuel-efficient than gas engines, even those with very high compression ratios. Diesel fuel is also more energy-dense than gasoline, meaning more energy per gallon. As a result, it's not uncommon for a diesel-powered car to get 50 mpg or higher.

Do diesels require a lot of maintenance? ›

Less Frequent Service

In addition, because diesel engines are more efficient than gas-powered engines, they dont wear down as quickly and they dont need as much maintenance. So even though diesel engine vehicles typically cost more, you make up the difference in fuel efficiency and less frequent service and repairs.

What are three disadvantages of diesel engines? ›

Diesel Cons:
  • Abysmal horsepower, slower speed.
  • Expensive fuel, limited gas stations with diesel.
  • Noisier and more rugged ride than gasoline-powered engines.
  • Produce emissions that emit carcinogens, nitrous oxides, and soot into the atmosphere.
  • Costlier repairs and maintenance.

What are the disadvantages of diesel? ›

Diesel fuel usually costs more. Servicing can be more expensive, although you don't need to do it as often. Diesel cars produce a lot more NO2. Diesel engines can be slightly noisier.

What is the average life of a diesel engine? ›

Understanding the Basics

Although it is difficult to pinpoint an exact number, the common lifespan of a diesel engine is typically between 300,000 and 500,000 miles, with some models even reaching 1,000,000 miles.

Is it cheaper to own a gas or diesel truck? ›

Diesel trucks are almost always more expensive. If you plan to purchase a diesel truck, expect to pay anywhere between $5,000-10,000 more than a gas truck under the same brand. Heavy-duty trucks cost even more. Diesel trucks do have some economic advantages.

What is the difference between diesel maintenance and gasoline maintenance? ›

For instance, diesel engine components require service for fuel filters and diesel exhaust fluid (DEF). Gasoline engines, on the other hand, have shorter oil change intervals and require periodic maintenance on spark plugs that don't exist on diesel engines.

What maintenance is required for a diesel engine? ›

Diesel engines operate under higher heat conditions than gasoline engines, necessitating frequent oil changes and quality assessments. Liquid additives during and after winter are also recommended to maintain peak performance.

Why are diesel cars not popular in the US? ›

The pump price of diesel is far more expensive than gasoline; even more than the premium fuel option. The savings of a diesel engine come with the fuel economy over the life of the engine. A diesel engine costs more to build and is more expensive to purchase.

Is it bad to drive diesel short distances? ›

To get the most benefit from a diesel engine, you need to log many miles on the highway, where engine design and increased fuel economy shine. In fact, if you do most of your driving in short-distance, low-speed city driving, you may end up clogging the engine's particulate filter, requiring additional maintenance.

What is the best diesel car to buy? ›

Best diesel cars
  • BMW 320d.
  • Vauxhall Astra 1.5 Turbo D (130)
  • Mercedes Benz S 350.
  • Land Rover Defender D300.
  • Citroen Berlingo.
  • Range Rover Sport D350.
  • Skoda Karoq 2.0 TDI 150.
  • Volkswagen Multivan.

How often do diesel cars need a good run? ›

The best and also the simplest tip here is to take a longer trip with the vehicle at certain intervals (e.g. twice a month). Here we recommend driving at least 70-100 miles non-stop at a constant speed. The type of fuel used is important to avoid damage to the engine or to prevent deposits in the engine.

Do diesel motors last longer than gas motors? ›

Along with producing tremendous amounts of torque (which helps get heavy cargo moving), diesel engines are highly efficient under load and typically last two to four times longer than a comparable gasoline-fired engine.

What lasts longer a diesel engine or a gasoline engine? ›

A gasoline-powered vehicle can typically operate for around 200,000 miles before it needs a serious overhaul, or be replaced with a new vehicle. But an amazing fact is that diesel engines can run for 1,000,000-1,500,000 miles before needing any major diesel repairs.

Is a diesel or gas truck better for daily drivers? ›

Reasons to Choose a Gas Truck

Acceleration and Horsepower – True, diesel engines tend to offer more torque. However, for many daily drivers, it's a vehicle's horsepower and acceleration specs that really matter. Gas-powered trucks are generally better at getting up to speed and passing other cars.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Pres. Carey Rath

Last Updated:

Views: 6048

Rating: 4 / 5 (41 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Pres. Carey Rath

Birthday: 1997-03-06

Address: 14955 Ledner Trail, East Rodrickfort, NE 85127-8369

Phone: +18682428114917

Job: National Technology Representative

Hobby: Sand art, Drama, Web surfing, Cycling, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Leather crafting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Pres. Carey Rath, I am a faithful, funny, vast, joyous, lively, brave, glamorous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.