Yoga, Pilates & Barre: The Key Differences And Benefits (2024)

Yoga, Pilates and barre are all low-impact disciplinesthat are great optionsfor at-home workouts.

They can allhelp to improve your flexibility, balance and posture while strengthening muscles to prevent the risk of injury.

While there are some similarities betweenthese threetraining styles—for instance, you might find yourself doing planks in a yoga, barre or Pilates class — they each have distinct qualities.Find out more about eachdiscipline so you can decide which oneis right for you.

How to compare and choose between yoga, Pilates and barre

If you’re thinking about trying a yoga, Pilates or barre class and wondering which is the best choicefor you, it pays to know the key differences – and benefits – before you roll out your mat.

Yoga, Pilates & Barre: The Key Differences And Benefits (1)

Feel grounded with yoga

Yoga is a total mind and body workout that requires flowing through a set series of exercises – called poses – while using the breath to focus the mind. The practice originated in India and each yoga pose has an English or Sanskrit name.

There are many different styles of yoga, from dynamic Vinyasa yoga to gentle and restorative yin, making it a great option for everyone.

If you’re a beginner looking to get started with yoga, the good news is that you don’t need any fancy equipment – although you may want a non-slip mat if you decide to start an at-home yoga practice.

Sweat instructor Phyllicia Bonanno’s Yoga with Phyllicia classes on the Sweat app are a gentle, accessible way to learn the fundamentals, with a focus on slower flows that help you find stability in each pose or posture.

If you’re ready for a challenge, try Ania Tippkemper’s Yoga with Ania or Sjana Elise’s Body And Mind (BAM) programs which both follow a powerful and dynamic Vinyasa style.

Why you should try yoga

Yoga is a great option as both a standalone practice or to complement your existing workout routine. According to the American Osteopathic Association, it can help increase strengthand flexibility and decrease the risk of injury.

Therestorative nature of yoga can also have a positive impact on your overall wellbeing, with the Mayo Clinic highlighting that a yoga practice canhelp you manage anxiety and stress.

Yoga, Pilates & Barre: The Key Differences And Benefits (2)

Strengthen your core with Pilates

Created by German gymnast Joseph Pilates in the early 20th century, the origins of Pilates are rooted in rehabilitation and building strength. Pilates consists of a series of controlled, sustained exercises that concentrate on form, rather than trying to hit a set number of reps.

The fundamentals of Pilates are based around stabilising the spine and pelvis, activating the abdominals, and using equipment such asresistance bands and rubber ringsto build in levels of resistance or tension.

In a typical Pilates classyou’ll perform a series of simple, repetitiveexercises with an emphasis on muscular exertion in the abdominals, lower back, hips, thighs and glutes. You’ll find yourself focusing on smaller movements that require you to stabilise yourback and core to complete the exercises.

No matter your age or fitness level, Pilates can be modified to suit everyone – even if you’ve just started working out.

Sweat’s Pilates instructor Sara Colqhhoun’s Pilates with Sara program blends traditional and contemporary Pilates with elements of functional movement training to increase flexibility, core strength and improve full-body muscle definition.

Why you should try Pilates

Including regular Pilates classes in your fitness routine will promote plenty of physical and mental benefits, including stronger muscles in your back, core and hips, better pelvis and hip alignment, increased flexibility, better balance, and a greater range of motion.

Yoga, Pilates & Barre: The Key Differences And Benefits (3)

Build muscular endurance with barre

Barre is based on a movement style originated by dancer Lotte Berk, who began teaching it in London in 1959. Barre combines ballet-inspired movements (the barre that gives this training style its name is used as a support for some ballet exercises which are typically done in a barre class) with functional strength exercises.

Think of barre as a fusion of Pilates, classical ballet moves and dynamic stretching. You'll use just the barre (you can also use a sturdy chair) for support, and your body weight or small pieces of equipment such as ankle weights orlow-weight dumbbells to add resistance while you perform a muscle-burning number of reps — the goal is to work the muscles to the point of fatigue.

Sweat instructor Britany Williams will challenge you in her Barre with Britany program, building strength and endurance. You’ll be working your muscles with minimal rest, learning new positions andproper form while simultaneously keeping up with your workout! It will get your heart rate up, but as barre is low-impact, it’s great for all fitness levels!

Why you should try barre

As a low-impact exercise, barre delivers similar benefits to both yoga and Pilates, including enhanced flexibility, improved posture and body alignment, and activated core muscles. The key difference isa barre workout teaches muscular control and endurance specifically in the hips and shoulders while integrating core stability by working your muscles to the point of fatigue.

Yoga, Pilates & Barre: The Key Differences And Benefits (7)Yoga, Pilates & Barre: The Key Differences And Benefits (8)

Yoga vs Pilates vs barre: Which is right for you?

Whether you love the flow of yoga, the control of Pilates or the technical aspect of barre work, you can’t go wrong by incorporating these low-impact exercises into your workout schedule. Commit to at least one of these classes each week and you’ll see improved strength, balance and flexibility.

You’re far more likely to stick to something if you enjoy it, so try a couple of classes to find the exercise that works for you. You might be surprised at what gets those endorphins flowing!

* Disclaimer: This blog post is not intended to replace the advice of a medical professional. The above information should not be used to diagnose, treat, or prevent any disease or medical condition. Please consult your doctor before making any changes to your diet, sleep methods, daily activity, or fitness routine. Sweat assumes no responsibility for any personal injury or damage sustained by any recommendations, opinions, or advice given in this article.

Yoga, Pilates & Barre: The Key Differences And Benefits (2024)

FAQs

Yoga, Pilates & Barre: The Key Differences And Benefits? ›

If your goal is to work on head-to-toe toning, muscular strength, and endurance, try barre classes. If your goal is to work on core strength, balance, and posture, try Pilates classes. If your goal is to work on flexibility, mindfulness, and breath, yoga will take a greater focus on this.

What are the main differences between yoga and Pilates? ›

The main difference between yoga and Pilates is that Yoga is a holistic practice that emphasises the integration of the mind, body, and spirit. Pilates is an exercise that focuses on good alignment, core strength, and muscular balance.

What are the benefits of barre and Pilates? ›

Both focus on improving flexibility, posture, and muscle tone through low-impact, precise exercises. Both barre and pilates offer an excellent workout and can help you get fitter, leaner, and improve your posture.

What gives you a better body yoga or Pilates? ›

If you want to increase your strength and flexibility, Pilates might be the better choice. If you want to improve your overall wellness, you might choose yoga. Still, much depends upon the particular classes available to you and the skills and qualifications of the instructors.

Which is better for weight loss, barre or Pilates? ›

Although Pilates offers elements to burn fat, Barre can help you burn fat quicker by speeding up your metabolism and increasing your cardiovascular endurance. Barre may not look like (or sound like) a tough workout, it does increase your heart rate. Barre is the winner when it comes to fat loss.

Which is better for seniors yoga or Pilates? ›

The benefits for both are huge and the evidence for both is strong. As a general rule, yoga focuses a bit more on stretching, and Pilates a bit more on strength. However, they will each lead to improvements in both components and it really depends on your teacher, your personal preferences and your goals.

What is more difficult Pilates or yoga? ›

Pilates is certainly a more intense workout that burns calories faster and produces physical results quicker, so you could make the argument that Pilates is the harder of the two. But again, everything comes down to what you wish to get out of the class and the methods your instructor takes to get you there.

Can you lose belly fat with barre? ›

Barre Workouts for Weight Loss

Barre workouts can be a fantastic addition to your fitness routine. If you want to shed those extra pounds, don't let the elegant and graceful movements fool you; these exercises can be surprisingly effective in burning calories and aiding in weight loss.

How many times a week should I do barre and Pilates? ›

We recommend you do the full workouts a minimum three-to-five times per week. Most people begin to see results as early as three weeks.

Does barre help with belly fat? ›

Because barre focuses heavily on balance and strength, your core is an integral part of the training. “As you use the abdominals to hold the body in a correct alignment, barre classes will give you a heavy core workout—perfect for keeping toned tummies in check,” says Willoughby.

Can Pilates change your body shape? ›

Studies have shown that a strong core achieved through Pilates resonates throughout the entire body, giving you long, lean, stabilizing muscles—while also trimming that waistline and sculpting your abs.

How many times a week should you do yoga or Pilates? ›

Since the benefits of Pilates vary so widely, an individual's frequency of practice will too. For example, if you're looking to increase flexibility or ease back pain, 1-2 sessions a week is a great start. Data supports the idea that the optimal frequency of stretching for improved flexibility is 6 times a week.

Is Pilates or yoga better for belly fat? ›

"In conclusion, while both yoga and Pilates offer unique benefits, if your goal is to specifically target belly fat or burn body fat, Pilates may be more effective due to its focus on muscle toning and strengthening."

What is harder, barre or Pilates? ›

Reformer classes are generally considered more challenging than mat pilates, though rest assured you'll get a bang for your buck regardless. Compared to barre, Pilates uses fewer, more controlled repetitions emphasising correct form and mind-muscle control, instead of elevating your heart rate and making you sweat.

Does barre or Pilates tone more? ›

Both strengthen and sculpt your muscles, can help relieve stress, get your heart rate up, and benefit your mental health. That said, if you're looking to build a rock-solid core, Pilates is the better choice, whereas if you prefer a dance-style workout, you might enjoy the repetitive beat of a barre class.

Is barre closer to yoga or Pilates? ›

A popular workout program that is rapidly gaining recognition and followers is the barre method. This fitness program is essentially a mixture of ballet-inspired exercises, yoga, and Pilates.

Do you lose more weight with yoga or Pilates? ›

Both Pilates and yoga are exercises designed to build strength and improve flexibility. Yoga and Pilates are both good for weight loss — but yoga, especially vinyasa yoga, burns more calories per hour. Deciding between Pilates and yoga comes down to personal preference and whichever gets you most excited to workout.

Is yoga or Pilates better for the pelvic floor? ›

Yoga provides superior benefits for improving incontinence compared with Pilates, as measured by the International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaire-Short Form. Yoga and Pilates are as effective as pelvic floor muscle training for decreasing the severity of stress urinary incontinence.

What makes Pilates different? ›

Pilates isolates individual muscle groups to ensure even muscular development so that you can improve the strength of your full body to reduce the risk of overworking certain muscles. Pilates lengthens & tones your muscles all over.

Is Pilates or yoga better for lower back pain? ›

Ultimately, the choice between yoga and Pilates for reducing back pain may be personal preference. If you'd rather mix your physical healing with a spiritual experience and breathwork, yoga may be for you. But if staying in the physical realm with your exercise routine sounds more palatable, consider Pilates.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Lidia Grady

Last Updated:

Views: 5834

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (65 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Lidia Grady

Birthday: 1992-01-22

Address: Suite 493 356 Dale Fall, New Wanda, RI 52485

Phone: +29914464387516

Job: Customer Engineer

Hobby: Cryptography, Writing, Dowsing, Stand-up comedy, Calligraphy, Web surfing, Ghost hunting

Introduction: My name is Lidia Grady, I am a thankful, fine, glamorous, lucky, lively, pleasant, shiny person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.